Could vitamin D help ward off suicide?
In a study of 1 million U.S. veterans, those prescribed vitamin D were nearly 50% less likely to attempt suicide over eight years, versus those who were not prescribed the supplements.
Web URL: Read this article on Medical Xpress
FAB RESEARCH COMMENT:
As the authors of this new study emphasise, this was not a clinical trial - so the findings can’t be taken as firm evidence that Vitamin D supplementation actually caused the very significant reduction in self-harm and suicide observed.However, when considered in the light of existing findings, it seems quite possible that this may be the case.
One clinical study found very low blood Vitamin D levels in patients who had attempted suicide - with 60% showing clinical level deficiency. And importantly, their blood levels were lower than both depressed patients and healthy controls. See:
And a recent systematic review of controlled clinical trials DID find a causal effect of Vitamin D supplements in alleviating depression, a known risk factor for suicide:
How much Vitamin D is enough?
Importantly, for effectiveness against clinical depression, this systematic review found that fairly high doses of Vitamin D may be needed - i.e. 50 mcg/day (2000 IU) or more.By contrast, in the UK the general population recommendation for Vitamin D supplementation is only 10 mcg/day (400 IU).
Individual needs will always differ, but factors known to increase the need for higher intakes of Vitamin D from supplementation include:
- low skin exposure to bright sunlight - as this, not diet, is the main natural source of Vitamin D.
- Indoor lifestyles therefore increase the risk of deficiency. And importantly, in the UK and countries at similar distance from the equator, no vitamin D at all can be made this way from October-March - so Vitamin D supplementation from Autumn-Spring is recommended for everyone
- darker skin colour - because other things being equal, darker skin requires more sunlight exposure than paler skin to produce the same amount of Vitamin D.
- Individuals with African or Asian ancestry are therefore at particularly high risk of Vitamin D deficiency in the UK, other Northern European countries, Canada and large parts of the US, as numerous studies have shown.
- low magnesium status - as low magnesium levels make vitamin D ineffective. Most people's diets fail to provided recommended intakes of magnesium - and deficiencies of this nutrient have repeatedly been linked with depression, anxiety and related conditions.
For more details of this new study, linking prescription of Vitamin D to a 50% reduction in suicide and self-harm, see:
For further information on Vitamin D and depression please see:
And for more information on the potential role of other aspects of nutrition in the prevention of self-harm and suicide (such as omega-3 fatty acids - which work with Vitamin D to regulate brain levels of serotonin) see also:
02/02/2023 - Medical Xpress
--------------------------------
A new study hints that treating low vitamin D levels with supplements might have a critical benefit for certain people: a decreased risk of attempting suicide.
--------------------------------
A new study hints that treating low vitamin D levels with supplements might have a critical benefit for certain people: a decreased risk of attempting suicide.
In a study of more than 1 million U.S. veterans, researchers found that those prescribed vitamin D were nearly 50% less likely to attempt suicide over eight years, versus those who were not prescribed the supplements.
The benefit was seen specifically among veterans who had low vitamin D levels to begin with, as well as Black veterans—who may be at greater risk of insufficient vitamin D stores.
Experts stressed that the study was not a clinical trial that directly tested vitamin D for reducing suicidal behavior. So it does not prove that supplements, per se, actually cause suicide risk to fall.
At the same time, it's known that vitamin D deficiency can cause depression-like symptoms, including mood changes and chronic fatigue, said Dr. Christine Crawford, a psychiatrist and associate medical director of the National Alliance on Mental Illness.
Crawford, who was not involved in the study, said that in her practice, she often has patients with depression symptoms tested for blood levels of vitamin D, as well as vitamin B12, folic acid and thyroid hormones. (Deficiencies in those vitamins, or thyroid hormone disturbances, can also cause depressive symptoms.)
"I think that medical evaluation is so important," Crawford said.
If a nutrient deficiency is caught, she noted, the solution is straightforward.
Crawford said that in her experience, detecting and treating a vitamin D deficiency can make a big difference.
"Within a few months, patients can have a significant improvement in mood and how they're feeling physically and mentally," she said.
"I think this is a great study," Crawford said of the new research, as it suggests the benefits of treating low vitamin D could extend to a lower risk of attempting suicide.
The findings were published Feb. 1 in the journal PLOS ONE.
In the study, researchers Jill Lavigne and Jason Gibbons found just over 660,000 patients who were prescribed vitamin D between 2010 and 2018 for various reasons. Around half had a vitamin D deficiency.
The researchers compared those veterans against the same number of vets who were not prescribed vitamin D, but were otherwise similar—in terms of age, sex, race, and physical and mental health diagnoses.
Vitamin D supplements contain either of two forms of the vitamin: D2 (ergocalciferol) or D3 (cholecalciferol). Most of the veterans on supplements were taking vitamin D3. In that group, 0.2% were treated for attempted suicide or self-harm during the study period. That compared with 0.36% of veterans not prescribed vitamin D.
There was a similar pattern among veterans prescribed vitamin D2: The rate was 0.27% who attempted suicide or otherwise harmed themselves, versus 0.52% of veterans without vitamin D prescriptions.
When the researchers weighed other factors, like physical and mental health conditions, vitamin D supplementation was still linked to a 45% to 48% lower risk of attempting suicide.
And it turned out that the association was strongest among veterans who had low vitamin D to start (blood levels lower than 20 ng/mL), and among Black veterans.
The body naturally synthesizes vitamin D when the skin is exposed to sunlight. But darker skin, with more melanin, results in less vitamin D production.
That might be why supplements appeared particularly protective among Black veterans, according to Lavigne, of the VA's Center of Excellence for Suicide Prevention in Canandaigua, N.Y.
She and Gibbons, a researcher at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, both stressed that this type of study does not prove cause-and-effect.
However, Gibbons voiced support for the approach that Crawford and other health professionals already take: evaluating patients with depression symptoms for low vitamin D.
Vitamin D is easy enough for people to get on their own. But Lavigne cautioned that the vitamin is stored in body fat, and it's possible to overdo it with supplements.
Plus, Crawford said, talking to your doctor about your symptoms, and possibly getting tested for other nutritional or thyroid issues, is important. It's also critical that people get any additional help they need—including talk therapy or medication, she said.
"No one is saying that vitamin D will eliminate all thoughts of suicide," Crawford stressed. But for some people, she added, it could be a "piece of the puzzle."
Food and Behaviour Research is a registered charity (No SC034604) and a company limited by guarantee (Co No SC 253448)
Newsletter Signup
Useful Links
Contact Us
FAB Research
23 Carlton Road
Oxford
OX2 7SA
Important Notice
Medical opinion and guidance should always be sought for any symptoms that might possibly reflect a known or suspected disease, disorder or medical condition. Information provided on this website (or by FAB Research via any other means) does not in any way constitute advice on the treatment of any medical condition formally diagnosed or otherwise.
Site by Redstone Websites. Easy to Use Web Content Management. 2024 © All Rights Reserved.